sunset from behind the wire

sunset from behind the wire

Tuesday, May 16, 2017

Commentary on North Korea

North Korea’s missile program is stimulating a weapons race in Northeast Asia. North Korea has the ability to start a weapons race, a war or other unpleasantness, but their finish always rests with the Allies.

In Japan

Japanese Defense Minister Inada told a Diet committee on 15 May that the government will try to improve its ability to intercept ballistic missiles. Inada said the government is researching a variety of options, including “Aegis Ashore”. 

She commented on a proposal by the ruling Liberal Democratic Party that the government consider granting the Self-Defense Forces permission to attack enemy bases. She said the government needs to take the proposal seriously and to bolster deterrence through the Japan-US Alliance.

Last November, Inada visited Guam for a demonstration of the Terminal High Altitude Area Defense system. The government favors the Aegis Ashore system. 

What Really Happened?

Japanese press reported on 12 May that on 18 April North Korea notified China, “We will conduct a nuclear test on 20 April.”
According to the press account, China informed the United States that it had received the notification from Pyongyang. China also warned North Korea that it would “close the China–North Korea border for a long time if it went through with the nuclear test.” 
“China confirmed that it had requested North Korea to refrain from conducting a nuclear test. The Chinese also told us that they informed North Korea that China would be taking sanctions action on their own if they did conduct further nuclear tests,” US Secretary of State Rex Tillerson said on 27 April. 
China told North Korea that the embargo would be complete, by land and by sea. On the night of 19 April, Chinese border police maintained the highest-level alert along the North Korean border in anticipation of a North Korean nuclear test. It never came.
This is the first open source report that accounts for North Korean behavior in the third week of April. This also is the first time China has exerted such pressure on North Korea and the first time North Korea has changed its behavior because of a non-military threat. China is the only country that can impose a complete embargo on North Korea, which would be unprecedented. China can wreck the North Korean economy. 

The Chinese warning explains the volleyball game at the nuclear test site, which was staged probably for the benefit of Chinese imagery systems. It also explains the shrillness of the 3 May North Korean media rant against China.

As for China’s persistent denial that it has the ability to influence North Korean behavior, that denial has been exposed as false. The Chinese found a way without using military force.

This is a text book case of a successful warning. The nuclear test did not occur because national decision makers received early and sufficient warnings that were regularly updated in time for them to take action to deter the nuclear test. Seldom do analysts obtain this kind of confirmation that warning worked.

The Russia Factor

In a press conference at the conclusion of China’s One Belt, One Road summit in Beijing, Russian 
President Putin said, "I want to confirm, we are against expansion of the nuclear powers club, including the Korean Peninsula, including North Korea."  
He also said, "What we have been observing lately in the world, in particular, outrageous violation of international law and invasion of the territory of foreign states, regime changes and so on, triggers this arms race," Putin said. While nuclear or missile tests are 'unacceptable', the international community should return to a dialogue with North Korea and 'stop intimidating' it."
I repeated Putin’s comments in full because elite, smug, incompetent US news outlets only reported the last line about dialogue and intimidation. 

Brief Conclusions

China has its hand on the North Korean throttle and everyone knows it. The only talks that matter are talks between China and North Korea. The US will defend its allies in Japan and South Korea, but any change needs to come from China and the dog on its leash.

If China wants to further militarize Japan and South Korea, it can. Thus it's protests about THAAD deployment and a mobilizing Japan are hollow. Removing the threat will calm things down and that's 100% a China problem.


6 comments:

  1. China's problem, China's solution. If I remember my history, China took over the problem from Russia. Big win for them?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. North Korea modeled itself after the old, defunct, Soviet Union. But it was China that invaded North Korea to push the UN troops back south. Ever since then it's been a client state of the Chinese. Under Mao, it was a buffer state and little more (not unlike the Warsaw Pact nations were in Eastern Europe). Since then it's become a problem and needs fixing (by them not by us).

      Delete
  2. Thanks for the full Putin quote and you'll notice the lying, elite, corrupt media is now pushing for Trump's impeachment. The phrase "crazed circus" springs to mind.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The mainstream media should ally itself to that evil clown in Austin if they want to complete the circle.

      Delete
  3. Thank you for the in-depth report and Putin's full statement.
    I appreciate it, as always.

    ReplyDelete

It's virtual - it's a mirage - it's life