sunset from behind the wire

sunset from behind the wire

Thursday, September 26, 2013

National Zapatista Liberation Army-- A Scam


The National Zapatista Liberation Army (EZLN) is gaining some serious momentum in Southern Mexico, where they find their base of support. The movement has been simmering for about forty years, with various charismatic figures trying to whip up opposition to the constituted Mexican government.  But all is not as it seems.

Context

The armed uprising in 1994 failed and in 2002, the EZLN signed a type of peace agreement with then President Fox in Santa Ana, California. The agreement established 32 autonomous municipalities within the Mexican state of Chiapas and thereby, ended the conflict. Or that was the intention of the moment. I was there at the signing. In fact, it took place in the conference room in my office.

Their Gripe

The National Zapatista Liberation Army is a communist movement that focuses on their assertion that Indians in Latin America have received less than they deserve because of globalization. Thus, their struggle is for social justice. They feel that the North American Free Trade Agreement is unfair (but never quite explain why that is). There is no question but what the Indians have received the "short end" of the deal when it comes to Mexican politics, but globalized trade would seem to have little to do with it.

Their leadership (guided by communists worldwide) came up with an interesting twist on traditional revolutionary movements:
...demand that the revolutionary armed forces not intervene in matters of civil order or the disposition of capital relating to agriculture, commerce, finances, and industry, as these are the exclusive domain of the civil authorities, elected freely and democratically.
Even though they are an armed revolutionary movement, they decided not to shoot at anyone. Therefore, they became a "peaceful revolutionary movement" and used that platform to gather support from NGO's which funded and sustained them over the past twenty years. From the early days, much of the advocacy for the revolution was carried out by the Society of Jesus (Jesuits) arm of the Catholic Church. Historically, the Catholic Church has taken an interest in Indian affairs in Mezoamerica. Organizing and sustaining revolutionary movements has been a Jesuit specialty. In the case of the EZLN, they've kept the revolution running thanks to generous contributions from US Corporations -- the very same corporations that are their sworn enemies.

If the reader senses irony here, the reader is on point. 

American corporations are solicited by the Society of Jesus to give Jesuits money to buy soap and Bibles  and to provide the poor indians in Chiapas with an education. The money is then used to fund a few revolutionary leaders in a lifestyle that they had not enjoyed before -- and the Jesuit Brothers live a lavish lifestyle on the proceeds. A few dollars go to schools.

SCAM? Yes. Because it's a "peaceful revolution", corporations fork over money and deduct it from their income tax.  Since the struggle for social justice is endless, so is the need for money. Thus you see Communism revealed for what it has always been in practice. A few community organizers make out well as do the movement's "leaders" while those behind the scenes live very well.

And what of the Maya and indigenous peoples of Mezoamerica? 

Nothing ever changes for them. 


10 comments:

  1. Viva Zapata! Where is Marlon when he's really needed?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Popular Fronts/Communist movements have always been a scam for the power and money hungry. It's not different here. (viva!)

    ReplyDelete
  3. If you actually want to learn something about the EZLN rather than just fitting them into your preconceived notions of what a communist (a designation they have never self-applied) movement is, this website might be a good start: http://compamanuel.wordpress.com/

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for your input, Anonymous. And yes, I've traveled to Chiapas, not just to Tuxtla Gutierrez, and yes, the indians have been treated like garbage by the national government. However, the EZLN is still a scam. Soap and bibles don't equal the money that is coming in from all sources - particularly Jesuit sources.

      Delete
  4. If they are truly progressive they will claim the right to carbon credits. So they can charge working people for the carbon they consume. Or emit. Or they could claim oxygen credits, charge people for breathing THEIR oxygen. I'm sure they'll think of some way to bilk hard working people.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. These people are pretty beat up, Opus. Their present standard of living is just about what the Conquistadors left them. And now the communists are using them as political pawns. They have no money to pay carbon credits. Maybe if they cremated their grandparents, they could hand over the ash as a partial payment...

      Delete
  5. It has often seemed to me that indigenous people would be better off left to live their lives in their own way. Maybe not a life style we could embrace, but still theirs. First do no harm.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Vulnerable people are always exploited. Hard targets are not. But your point is well taken.

      Delete
  6. I agree with Brighid, let them be Communist, if they choose...in their villages or cities...but it has to be quarantined, because it kills like the plague.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I don't think that the Indians want to be communist or capitalist. They simply want to get out of the hole that they're in. And MEXGOV will never let them do that -- neither will the communists who use them like pawns.

      Delete

It's virtual - it's a mirage - it's life